Two US financial regulators have started separate rulemaking that could change how ordinary Americans trade crypto with borrowed money and how professional money managers hold digital assets for clients. The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) has asked for public comment on a framework for leveraged retail crypto trading. The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has proposed custody rules for crypto held by registered investment advisers and regulated funds.

Both are early-stage processes, not final rules. They matter because each tackles a question the US market has struggled to answer: where retail leverage should happen, and how institutions can hold crypto safely within existing investor-protection rules.

What the CFTC is asking about

According to a JD Supra summary published on 16 October, the CFTC wants public input on a framework that would bring leveraged retail crypto transactions onto regulated exchanges.

"Leveraged" trading means a customer puts up only part of a position's value and borrows or is financed for the rest. Gains and losses are magnified as a result. For retail customers, this kind of trading often happens on offshore platforms or through products that sit outside the full set of US exchange protections.

The National Law Review, writing on 14 October, describes the same initiative a little more broadly: as a proposed framework governing retail trading of crypto assets and markets. The two accounts don't contradict each other, but they put the weight in different places. JD Supra focuses on leverage and moving activity onto regulated venues. The National Law Review frames it as a wider look at retail crypto markets.

Neither summary gives the detailed requirements, eligibility criteria or a comment deadline. Readers should treat any specific figures circulating elsewhere with caution until they have checked them against the CFTC's own release.

What the SEC has proposed

On the securities side, law firm A&O Shearman reported on 15 October that the SEC has proposed a custody framework for crypto assets held by registered investment advisers and regulated funds.

"Custody" here means who actually holds and safeguards client assets, and under what conditions. With traditional securities, custody rules are meant to keep client assets separate from the adviser's own and to protect them from loss or misuse. Crypto complicates this because control of an asset depends on who holds the private keys, the cryptographic credentials that authorise transfers.

A dedicated framework would aim to set out how those principles apply to digital assets. The available summary does not say which custodians would qualify, how keys would need to be managed or what audit and reporting duties would follow.

Who is affected

The two proposals reach different parts of the market:

  • Retail traders who use leverage on crypto could eventually have a US-regulated route for that activity, if the CFTC moves ahead.
  • Exchanges and brokers serving retail customers would need to consider whether and how to offer leveraged products within the CFTC framework.
  • Registered investment advisers that manage crypto for clients, or want to, would be directly covered by the SEC proposal.
  • Regulated funds holding crypto assets would also fall under the SEC's custody framework.
  • Custody providers serving advisers and funds would be affected indirectly, because their clients' compliance would depend on how custodians are treated.

How market participants can respond

The main tool for anyone affected is the public comment process. Regulators publish their questions or draft rules, collect written responses, and may revise the proposal before adopting anything final.

For traders, comments can address practical concerns such as access, cost and the protections they would expect on a regulated venue. Brokers and exchanges are likely to focus on operating requirements and whether the framework makes it workable to serve retail clients onshore. Fund managers and advisers can respond on custody arrangements they consider workable, and on the operational and cost effects of any new requirements.

Because the summaries do not give deadlines, firms planning to comment should take submission dates and procedures from the official CFTC and SEC releases rather than secondary coverage.

Risks and open questions

Bringing leveraged retail trading onto regulated exchanges would not remove the core risk of leverage. Magnified exposure means losses can exceed what a trader expects, whatever the venue. Regulation can change the protections around that risk but not the risk itself.

On custody, the details will decide the outcome. A framework that is too narrow could limit which providers advisers can use. One that is too loose could fail to deliver the protection custody rules exist for. The current summaries don't show where the SEC has drawn these lines.

There is also a coordination question. The CFTC and SEC are acting on separate tracks, and how the two frameworks fit together for firms working across both regimes isn't clear from the material available.

What to watch

  • Comment deadlines: the official CFTC and SEC releases will set the windows for public input. That is the next concrete milestone for both proposals.
  • Published comments: responses from exchanges, brokers, asset managers and custodians will show where industry support and resistance sit.
  • Further CFTC action: because the CFTC is at the request-for-comment stage, watch for whether it follows with a formal rule proposal.
  • Revisions to the SEC proposal: any changes between the proposed and final custody framework, especially on which custodians qualify.
  • Signs of coordination: any joint statements or aligned guidance from the two agencies on crypto activity that crosses their jurisdictions.