Coinkite, the Toronto company that makes the Coldcard bitcoin hardware wallet, is being sued in a proposed class action. The suit claims a firmware defect made some wallets create guessable recovery phrases, and that attackers used this to take more than $140 million in bitcoin. A hardware wallet exists to keep private keys secret, so the case asks a hard question: who pays when the security device itself is allegedly the weak point?

The most detailed account of the complaint comes from Bitcoin.com News. The Globe and Mail also reported the filing and called it a hack "reported at $140 million". Bitcoin.com puts the losses at more than that figure. Both numbers come from the lawsuit's own estimates, not from a court finding.

What the lawsuit claims

The claim was filed on 11 September 2026 in Ontario's Superior Court of Justice. It names Coinkite Inc. and its co-founders, Rodolfo Novak and Peter D. Gray. The lead plaintiff is Amir Reza Naderi, who lives in Los Angeles.

The core allegation concerns seed phrases, also called recovery phrases. These are lists of words that encode a wallet's private keys. Anyone holding the phrase can rebuild the wallet and spend its funds. Their security depends on being truly random, so that nobody can guess them.

The complaint says a firmware update released in March 2021 broke that randomness. It blames a "build and link integration error". According to the complaint, this made affected devices use Yasmarang, a software number generator that ships with MicroPython, in place of the hardware random number generator they were meant to use. Software generators like this can produce output that is far easier to predict. If the starting conditions can be worked out, the "random" words can be recreated.

The suit says this allowed attackers to rebuild private keys remotely, without ever touching the wallets. It describes the flaw as one that "undermined the entire purpose and function of the device".

How the thefts allegedly unfolded

The complaint says attackers began exploiting the weakness on 30 July 2026. In the first wave, about 594 BTC, worth around $38 million, was allegedly taken in 25 minutes. The suit says later thefts pushed total losses above $140 million.

Naderi says he personally lost 1.22940052 BTC, worth about $79,764, through unauthorised transfers on 6 August. That was a week after Coinkite's public disclosure. The gap matters to the plaintiffs' argument about how customers were warned.

The complaint also alleges that bitcoin engineer James O'Beirne warned Coinkite about the vulnerability in May 2025, more than a year before the thefts began. This is one of the more serious claims in the filing, and so far it is untested.

Coinkite's response and the disclosure question

Coinkite disclosed the vulnerability publicly on 30 July and released corrective firmware the next day. But a firmware update only changes how new seeds are made. Any recovery phrase created by the faulty code stays weak. To be protected, owners had to generate a new phrase and move their bitcoin to it.

The lawsuit argues Coinkite should have contacted affected customers directly, since it had their contact details, instead of relying on a public announcement. It also challenges the liability limits in Coinkite's customer terms, arguing that consumer protection law overrides clauses that restrict lawsuits and compensation.

When Bitcoin.com News asked about the case, Coinkite said: "We can't comment on pending litigation." It added that it expects to publish a full postmortem within days. The company says this will cover the cause of the seed-generation incident, how it was fixed, and independent verification of the fix.

What is known and what is still unproven

Some facts are clearer than others. Coinkite has publicly acknowledged a seed-generation problem and shipped a fix. The 30 July disclosure date also matches the date the complaint gives for the first thefts.

Most of the rest is still allegation:

  • the exact technical cause and which firmware versions were affected;
  • whether every theft counted in the $140 million figure came from this flaw;
  • whether Coinkite was warned in May 2025 and what it did in response;
  • whether the company's liability limits will hold up.

The proposed class covers personal-use buyers of the Coldcard Mk2, Mk3, Mk4, Mk5 and Q. That list sets out who the plaintiffs want to represent. It does not confirm that every one of those devices produced a weak seed. The plaintiffs are seeking compensatory and punitive damages and other relief. No damages have been awarded, and the court has not yet ruled on whether the case can go ahead as a class action.

What Coldcard owners should check

The sources do not give a full list of affected firmware versions or setup methods. Coinkite's postmortem is the place to look for that. Based on what has been reported, owners can still start with these questions:

  1. When and how was your seed created? The complaint says the problem began with firmware released in March 2021. A phrase generated on a Coldcard since then is the main concern.
  2. Have you updated past the 31 July fix? The update protects new seeds only. It does not repair old ones.
  3. Have you created a new seed and moved your funds? Coinkite's guidance, as described in coverage of the case, was that affected users needed a fresh recovery phrase and a transfer of their bitcoin to it.
  4. Have you checked for unexplained transactions? Owners who lost funds may want to record transaction IDs and dates, which could matter if the class is certified.

Moving funds costs a network fee and carries its own risk of mistakes. Owners should follow the manufacturer's official instructions and be wary of anyone who contacts them offering "recovery" help. Scammers often target users after a high-profile breach.

What to watch

  • Coinkite's postmortem: on 22 October the company said it would publish this within days. Look for the exact affected firmware range and details of the independent verification.
  • Class certification: the Ontario court has to decide whether the case can proceed on behalf of all Mk2, Mk3, Mk4, Mk5 and Q buyers.
  • The May 2025 warning: whether evidence emerges to support or rebut the claim that Coinkite was warned before the thefts.
  • Loss figures: whether independent on-chain analysis supports the estimate of more than $140 million, or produces a different number.