In one week, prediction markets showed both how much money they now make and how unsettled their legal footing still is. Kalshi raised $1 billion, and Robinhood reported that event contracts earned it more than crypto did last quarter. At the same time, Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) Chair Michael Selig said the agency is ready to take its fight with state governments over these markets all the way to the Supreme Court. The answer to who regulates them will decide whether the business can keep running under one national rulebook.
The money flowing into event contracts
Event contracts let people trade on how a real-world event will turn out, such as an election, an economic data release or a football game. A contract usually pays a fixed amount if the event happens and nothing if it does not.
Kalshi announced its Series G on 29 October. The round raised $1 billion at a $40 billion post-money valuation and was co-led by Wellington Management and Sequoia, according to crypto.news. Baillie Gifford, Andreessen Horowitz, Coatue, CapitalG and Morgan Stanley Investment Management also took part. The company says it has more than 30 million accounts and annualised trading volume above $1 trillion.
Kalshi said it will spend the money on institutional sales, distribution and product development, and on expanding into Latin America and Europe. It also plans products that go beyond prediction markets, including indices, single-stock perpetual futures and compute markets.
Robinhood's event business now earns more than crypto
Robinhood's results show how quickly this has become a meaningful line of revenue. CryptoSlate reports that the broker made $104 million from event contracts in the first quarter, $156 million in the second and $173 million in the third. That adds up to $433 million so far this year.
The third-quarter figure made up about 12.1% of Robinhood's $1,424 million in total net revenue. Crypto revenue was $120 million, down 55% from a year earlier. Event contracts first overtook crypto in the second quarter.
Other platforms are reporting much smaller or harder-to-compare numbers. Coinbase said its prediction business has passed $200 million in annualised net revenue. That figure projects a recent quarter forward over a full year, so it is not the same as revenue actually earned. Gemini earned $524,000 from predictions in the second quarter, about 1.2% of its total revenue. Coinbase CFO Alesia Haas said this income moves less with crypto prices, which helps the company through market cycles.
Robinhood's own filings also point to the risk. The company warned that enforcement actions, lawsuits or changes in the law could stop it from offering event contracts at all.
The CFTC's case for federal control
"We're prepared to fight these challenges all the way up to the Supreme Court," Selig said on 30 October, as reported by Crypto Briefing. Since its first lawsuits in April, the agency has filed 10 federal cases against states, including Arizona, Connecticut, Illinois and Utah.
The CFTC relies on the Commodity Exchange Act. It argues the law gives the agency exclusive authority over futures and swaps traded on designated contract markets (DCMs), which are exchanges registered with and supervised by the CFTC. In its view, federal law preempts, or overrides, state gambling rules aimed at those venues.
The agency has also filed amicus briefs in four federal appeals courts and one state supreme court. An amicus brief is a filing from a party that is not directly in the case but has a stake in how it is decided. Platforms caught up in the disputes include Kalshi, Polymarket and Crypto.com/Nadex.
Utah turns the dispute into a criminal case
Many states treat sports and election contracts as gambling, and Utah has gone further than any other. On 28 October it filed 13 felony charges against KalshiEX and named CEO Tarek Mansour and COO Luana Lopes Lara as co-defendants, CryptoSlate reports.
The charges come from an undercover investigation. A state agent opened an account with a Utah address and debit card and placed 12 sports wagers totalling $114.87 between 13 and 26 September. The first was a $10 bet on a Dallas Cowboys–New York Giants game. According to the filing, Kalshi checked his location, confirmed he was in Utah, accepted the trade anyway and charged a 44-cent fee. Both executives were issued summonses rather than arrest warrants. Kalshi called the case a "crazy overreach" and accused Utah of "playing politics".
The criminal case adds to a civil suit Utah filed on 20 October. That suit seeks to bar Kalshi from offering contracts on sports, elections and politics to Utah residents, to require court-approved geolocation controls (technology that blocks users by location) and to make Kalshi give up its profits from these trades. The CFTC sued Utah on 26 October to stop the state enforcing its gambling laws against federally regulated markets.
Early rulings point in different directions
The sources describe the legal record differently. Crypto Briefing says early rulings have favoured the CFTC, with preliminary injunctions granted in the Arizona and Illinois cases. CryptoSlate notes that Utah won an important ruling in August, when a federal judge rejected Kalshi's argument that federal law blocked the state from enforcing its gambling laws. The Tenth Circuit then refused to pause enforcement while Kalshi appeals.
The states are also organising. On 29 October, 37 state attorneys general filed a brief supporting Utah's authority in that appeal. With different courts reaching different conclusions, the dispute could produce a circuit split, meaning federal appeals courts in different regions disagree. Splits like that are a common route to the Supreme Court.
For the platforms, the outcome decides how they can operate. A CFTC win would let them work under one federal rulebook. A win for the states could force them to block contracts state by state and open them to claims for revenue already earned. That would put the growth Robinhood and Kalshi are reporting at risk.
What to watch
- The Tenth Circuit appeal in Kalshi's case against Utah, now backed by 37 attorneys general, is the main test for the states' position.
- The CFTC's lawsuit against Utah, filed 26 October, and whether the Arizona and Illinois injunctions survive appeal.
- The Utah criminal proceedings against Kalshi and its founders, and whether other states bring similar charges.
- Any circuit split among the appeals courts where the CFTC has filed briefs. A split would make Supreme Court review much more likely.
- Next quarter's earnings from Robinhood and Coinbase, to see whether event-contract revenue keeps growing while the legal fight continues.
